The most fun thing about seeing students as adults when the last time. you saw them they were kids is hearing their life stories. Once in a. while they become friends. The response to my post about meeting up with Jean who was in my computer classes and ...
‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ 

Click here to read this mailing online.

Your email updates, powered by FeedBlitz

 
Here is a sample subscription for you. Click here to start your FREE subscription


"Ed Notes Online" - 5 new articles

  1. Meeting up with a Former Student (part 2) - What we talked about for 4 hours
  2. Every teacher's dream as Long Ago Student Reaches Out
  3. The Chosen: UFT Spends Your Dues Sending People to Conferences
  4. The Caucus Role in UFT in Elections: The ICE Experience
  5. NYC Retirees Protest with National Organizations Against Mayor Eric Adams Monday, September 30, 2024
  6. More Recent Articles

Meeting up with a Former Student (part 2) - What we talked about for 4 hours

The most fun thing about seeing students as adults when the last time you saw them they were kids is hearing their life stories. Once in a while they become friends.
 
The response to my post about meeting up with Jean who was in my computer classes and part of a gender stem initiative has gotten an amazing response on Facebook from former students, former colleagues, family and friends.While I had often thought about what happened to Jean over the years because she clearly had enormous potential, I hadn't had the kind of relationship with her I had with my regular classroom students and barely knew her.

Every teacher's dream as Long Ago Student Reaches Out

The last time I saw her was 30 years ago. She was 12. 
We met to catch up at 11:30. Four hours later we were still talking about a million things. The past, the present and the future. Her major memory was an overnight visit to my house with four other 7th grade girls, something I would get arrested for that today.
October 12, 2024
 
I only told half the story. I've met with former students over the years and look forward to these meetings. Despite telling them to call me Norm, they still call me Mr. Scott -- to them it's still teacher/student. Those students had been in my class for the entire year, so a different relationship totally than the one I had with Jean, which was based on a short-time frame project we did that included an overnight visit and stay over at my house.
 

When Jean first contacted me two weeks ago the email was as good as any teacher could expect. And follow-up texts showed a level of enthusiasm for our meeting that pumped me up. But would the actual meeting come down to? Chatting and then saying goodbye, possibly forever? 
 
Well, from the first seconds I opened the door to my apartment, Jean's enthusiasm infected me. In my previous post I described how Jean was on a team of girls who built a bridge and were feted at a number of events set up by the Erector Set PR firm. But she remembered precious little of all that, to my surprise. She did remember vividly the visit to my house and that there was a limo ride. So I filled her in on the entire story as chronicled in my previous post. 
 
The plaque given to us at the AMNH somehow survived Sandy hurricane and is still hanging in my basement. Jean is quoted in the article. She didn't remember.




 
 
Jean had indicated that now that she had one child in the school and a 3 year old to follow, and as a new member of the PTA and the SLT, she wanted to know a lot more about how the system functions and what to expect.

She came to the right person. So we did a lot on the school level issues and I explained the district (CEC) and city (PEP) issues but also went back to some history of the local school boards. I knew something about the recent politics at the school and gave her the context and some of the pressures put on the principal.
 
I'm sure it was overload. But then she asked about issues related to reading and math problems and general curricula and she stimulated my aging brain to touch base with my ideas on how kids learn - and how excited I had always been about trying new things. I told her about my attempt to teach chess and do robotics and ideas I have about how you can do an entire curricula by doing theater. I explained that in 5 minutes of a kid reading aloud I could tell if he needed phonics. I'd bet her kid didn't need phonics to any extent, yet the phonics police are out there forcing every kid to go through it. I had to really recall the often frustrating experience in teaching reading to a full class. My MA in reading instruction was geared to one on one where you diagnose the problem with reading through a battery of tests and then design a corrective, all of this impossible in a full classroom. The best advice for improving reading is to read a lot but  reading can be a chore if you have to struggle. I have a thesis: Unlock the block and once you do there is no longer a need to teach reading to that child. Anyway -- as usual I got wrapped up and talked too long - who me? No, actually I did a lot of listening.

I mentioned I taught the "one" (top) class only once or twice and she had no idea what I was talking about. So we went into homo and hetero and tracking based on test scores. She understood how difficult it must be for teachers to teach a wide range of skill levels and we explored the the pros and cons.

Having spent most of the past 25 years focused on ed politics, going back to my progressive education roots was so exciting. And since Jean is interested in trying to get some things going at the school, I can see myself getting involved. The problem may be that the school is in transition to a new principal and we know how that game may work out. When I taught there the principal had zero interest in exciting programs. It was all about testing. So what else is new? Jean was surprised to find her child had been tested in kindergarten. I sadly informed her the "play with blocks" days are dead. 

So that led to the profit and politics of testing and the anti-public, pro charter, attack on public education and how Bloomberg turned the system into one where schools compete. She wanted to know if principals worked together to support each other. I rolled by eyes but promised to introduce her to Julie C who was one principal who is exceptional. I also plugged her into Leonie Haimson's listserve so she can see the educational issues on the table.

As we talked my energy level kept rising. We talked computer programming and neural networks and AI. And I'm sure even more about things I've already forgotten.
 
Jean went through her extensive career path in computer science, finance and her getting hit professionally with the 2000 dot.com crash and then at her next phase the 2008 Lehman Bros crash. And the journey to Silicon Valley and back and the two year see the world tour with her future husband who she met at Stuyvesant, and their marriage in Dubrovnik (one of my favorite places), Croatia.

Well, it was getting on toward 3:30 and I wanted to show Jean a bit of Murray Hill, a neighborhood I've grown to love, walked her to Grand Central to say goodbye, I hope not for the last time as there is so much more to talk about and if you know me, I sort of like to talk.

------
One side story. Jean went to IS 318, the flagship middle school in district 14. She had a vague memory of how she got there. I explained it to her. 
Schools were competitive even before Bloomberg. In late June, 1993 I received a call from the principal of 318. He and I had always been on opposite sides politically, so I was surprised. He wanted to know why Jean was going to a middle school in neighboring Dist 32 and not his school. "We need to keep our top students in the district." I felt I was in the middle of a recruitment war. It was clear that highly rated school like 318 fought for every top level student. The school she had chosen in Dist 32 had a great rep, so I told him I didn't think there was much I can do. He asked me to talk to her and her parents and just ask them to stop by his school. And sure enough, when I had to gather the girls to work on the project the next fall, Jean was going to 318. Of course she went on to Stuyvesant and she mentioned that there were about 20-25% Asian students then.

On Thursday, she had no memory other than she and her parents had visited the other school and somehow she ended up at 318. I connected the dots.

           

Every teacher's dream as Long Ago Student Reaches Out

The last time I saw her was 30 years ago. She was 12. 

We met yesterday to catch up at 11:30. Four hours later we were still talking about a million things. The past, the present and the future. Her major memory was an overnight visit to my house with four other 7th grade girls, something I would get arrested for that today.
 
 
Friday, October 11, 2024
 
About two weeks ago, I received an invitation to attend the retirement luncheon at PS 147K of the principal, Sandra Noyola but I was in the midst of a chemo session and didn't have the energy to go. Sandy has an interesting history - a student, para, teacher, principal in District 14. She told me a parent with a first grader at the school had asked her about me and I gave Sandy my email. A few days later I received am email from the student that every teacher dreams of. And I had relatively little contact with her since I was not her classroom teacher. So let me explain.
 
I have gotten together with former students before, but they were mostly from the years when I taught them in 4th, 5th and 6th grade. Any elem classroom teacher will tell you how intense living together for a year can be. But my last such class was in 1985 after 17 years of self-contained elementary school classroom teaching, the infantry of the education system. I left for a sabbatical and another year off to finish my Masters in computer science and when I came back I became a cluster teacher, a very different job and experience with students. This student had me for computer cluster at most once or twice a week. 

But we had one special project that included her and a whole bunch of girls in what we called the Girls Engineering Club at PS 147. That club came about at the inspiration of a colleague, Mary Hoffman, a great special ed teacher, a novelist and avid searcher of scientific inquiry who received a grant for closing the scientific gender gap and was looking for a project. 
 
I had been accumulating Erector Sets and Lego materials in my very large computer lab, with access to an empty room across the hall and was fooling around with early level robotics. And thus was born the Friday after school club, both Mary and I as volunteers. Jean was one of the girls, one of two Asian kids in a school that was 95% Hispanic and black. She told me today that the club gave her one of the few opportunities to bond with other students that she was missing in her regular class. 

I was a big fan of the Gilbert Erector Sets as a kid even if my parents wouldn't get me one. I was in a toy store one day in the early 1990s and saw an Erector set and noticed it was no longer Gilbert but Mecanno, a French Company with an office in the Empire State Building. So I called. A woman with a French accent picked up (I learned later she was the sister of the president of the company). I told her I was a teacher in Williamsburg and interested in using Erector Sets in my classroom and she was very interested. She said no teacher had every contacted them. A few days later she called back and said they were donating 4 sets to my classroom and they were setting up a national contest and hoped I could enter.

It was the end of the 92-93 school year and I got 5 girls from the club together and suggested they use all 4 kits to build as big a suspension bridge as they could - I thought of

the Bayonne bridge, the world's longest steel-arch bridge, as a model.

Anyway, they built the bridge,with a little bit of sagging, and graduated to 7th grade (Jean was the valedictorian) and I left for the summer. I received a call from a PR firm in the fall saying they didn't have an entry from me for their contest. The bridge was looking a bit shabby. They wanted pictures of the bridge and the girls, who were no longer in the school. So I had to track them down and get them to come after school to spruce up the bridge, fix the sag, and low and behold we won the $1500 dollar first prize and a big article in the NY Times that went viral. 
 
The PS 147 Girls Engineering Club made some national and international news and they were feted as special ceremonies at the Museum of Natural History, an evening ceremony at science event, a visit and tour of the operations at the George Washington Bridge and an invitation to the Sally Jesse Raphael show on Take Your Daughter to work day with Gloria Steinem on the panel and they would send a limo to pick us all up.

My only solution to making this early morning call work was to have the girls stay over at my house. I think it may have been Easter vacation. One of the mothers was reluctant. Are you sure you have a wife who will be there? I assured her I had a wife. And so we had pizza for dinner and we gave the girls our spare two bedrooms to figure out the sleeping arrangements while my wife and I huddled through the sounds of pillow fights. And getting 5 girls up at the crack of dawn to get ready for the limo was a slice of parenting.

Well, all went fine and the afternoon limo driver dropped the girls off at the school and us back to Rockaway.

And that was about it for my contact with Jean. 
 
Until yesterday.

Coming next: a 4 hour journey of her wonderful history of adventure through the academic world of Stuyvesant HS through college and grad school at MIT. And how Jean remembers the bridge event. Hint: She vividly remembers the big skylight in my house and how much that visit lodged in her memory, even more than the entire bridge project and how much visiting a teacher's home for the only time meant to her. She remembers having ridden in a limo but had not necessarily connected it to the TV show. Lesson learned: sometimes its worth risking arrest.

           

The Chosen: UFT Spends Your Dues Sending People to Conferences

Below is the spending voted on by Unity Caucus controlled AdCom and rubber stamped by the Unity exec bd, many of whom I am sure have benefited by being amongst The Chosen. This is from a recent UFT Exec Bd meeting which takes place every two weeks and each meeting is loaded with these junkets.
 
Before I get to the nitty gritty numbers, let me state I am not against a union sending reps to important conferences. Of course, define "important". The question is who are the people going and how do they get chosen? I see this as another one of the perks they hand out to keep people loyal. 
Motion:       To send 4 members to the National Council of Negro Women, Inc. 61st National Convention on October 9-13, 2024, in Baltimore, MD at a cost of $2,159 per person.
4x2,159 - about $8636. (cause I'm too lazy)  Carried
 
Motion:       To send 4 members to the NAACP’s 88th Annual New York State Conference on October 11-13, 2024, in Armonk, NY at a cost of $1,058 per person.
4x1,058 - about $4232   Carried
 
Motion:       To send 4 members to the CASEL Social & Emotional Learning Exchange Conference on November 12-14, 2024, in Chicago, IL at a cost of 2,305 per person.
4x2305 - $9220 Carried

Motion:       To send 4 members to the New York State Teachers of English to Speakers of Other Languages (NYSTESOL) Conference on November 14-16, 2024, in Rochester, NY at a cost of 1,635 per person. 
4x1635 -- $6540 Carried
 
Motion:       To send 5 members to the ACTE’s Career Tech Vision Conference on December 4-7, 2024, in San Antonio, TX, at a cost of $2,660 per person.
5x2660 --- $13000
 
Total for this round = c. $42,000 of your dues money. Amen.
 
 
           

The Caucus Role in UFT in Elections: The ICE Experience

The Caucus model works very well for Unity over 62 years. Not so well for the other caucuses. 

The premise for his and succeeding series of posts is that caucuses in the UFT are a necessity, but I question whether they should be the main driving force in UFT elections. I agree with their argument that they have the infrastructure and I don't preclude them using that infrastucture to support the effort. But they want control and that is where I push back.

That model hasn't worked very well but this time after the retiree and para and TRS elections, which had some caucus, but not all support, there is a feeling the model can work this time if there is a coalition like UFC from 3 years ago. I disagree. The vote totals for UFC were not much better than they were in 2016, but Unity votes slipped. A coalition might win this by default instead of a mass show of support. That would still be a leadership even if not Unity from the top. Without a major influx of new blood, mimicking the success of RA (which did have a massive influx of new blood even if from old people) will be impossible. Also can RA hold onto its 63% support if the Medicare issue fades.
Sunday, Oct. 6, 2024

Technically a caucus is any two or more people who come together over common interests. But in the UFT they mean a group that competes in UFT elections. A group that isn't interested in elections is more of a club.

The very fact there are competing groups that only come together for UFT elections to challenge and otherwise go their separate ways is the best friend Unity Caucus has. Let's face it, caucuses with a major aim of recruiting, generally put their own interests over the bigger picture, which is ending Unity's reign over the UFT. In fact over the 55 years I've been active in resistance groups, there have been few between elections examples of caucuses working together, Unity's best friend. This year, things may only get worse.

Why ICE was different

Let me just say that ICE was a factor in UFC in the 2022 election with James Eterno leading the way. Without James I have no stomach for making a case for ICE to have a share equal to other groups. ICE is not a caucus anymore in the traditional sense but still a collection of people with influence. In fact we are meeting on zoom tonight.

My experience in helping form ICE in late 2003 was a bit different than how other groups began. It was sort of serendipity.

The major oppo caucus, New Action, had just made a deal to work with Unity. I ran into Michael Fiorillo at a joint Unity/New Action rally and he was shaking his head. "What do you make of the NAC argument that Bloomberg is such a threat we need bipartisanship?" I said that kills the voices of resistance. We should get some of the gang together to talk about it. And so we did.

Teachers for a Just Contract had decided to become a formal election caucus. I had met a bunch of people who were not happy with TJC and its ideoligically driven program that at times seemed to be grafted onto the UFT but didn't touch on so many issues of concern, so I called them together, not to form a caucus, but to discuss the situation. Was NAC right to ally with Unity? Did TJC politics, molded by the ideologies driving the group, work for people? Some of us had attended a few TJC meetings and came away unhappy. 

This pre-ICE group meeting attracted over 20 people, including James and Camille Eterno, Ellen Fox and Lisa North who had left NAC (or been asked to leave). Most people were leftists of some sort but also pushed back against the TJC line of what they saw as a shallow, ideology driven program - which some recognize remnants in the current program MORE, with roots back to TJC, offers today. 

ICE decided to run in the 2004 election to raise crucial issues ignored by others

The meeting and those that followed were very program driven on issues no other group were focused on: the danger of mayoral control, high stakes testing, closing schools, attacks on teacher control of the classroom, class size, and others, all issues fundamentally ignored by the other caucuses. Three weeks later, we decided to form Independent Community  of Educators (ICE), not as a permanent caucus, but for the election in order to put forth our program in the NY Teacher. We did unite with TJC on the high school candidates only and surprisingly we won those 6 seats. It was only after that election that the group decided to stay together as a caucus and be active at the Exec Bd to support Jeff Kaufman, James Eterno and Barbara Kaplan-Alpert out winning HS candidate.

  • Independent: Left leaning, we are non-sectarian and not tied to any party or tendency.
  • Community: We are part of a broader community than UFT members in a school.
  • Educators: We are broader than just teachers and include secretaries, paras, etc.

There is some irony that I helped found yet another caucus when I had always advocated bringing everyone together into one big tent, which I had tried to do with Ed Notes back in 2001 when I called all caucuses together for a few meetings to work together for the next election -- before a fistfight broke out and I gave up.

ICE Uncaucused

The caucus model did not work out very well for ICE. We ran with TJC in 2007 and 2010 with little progress (NAC was still in alliance with Unity and was granted a number of exec bd seats and jobs), which is why we shifted to a non-caucus group called GEM (Grassroots Education Movement) where we did amazing work for two or three years - not focusing on  UFT stuff, we fought charters, high stakes testing, closing schools and made a great movie. Then we got sucked into forming a new caucus (MORE) and GEM died. Some of us think that was a major mistake. It turned out the new caucus model hasn't worked out very well either in terms of taking power in the UFT.

Coming next: 
So why don't all the groups form one big caucus? 
Examining other UFT caucuses on their success and failures.
Offering a New Paradigm for the next UFT election.
 
 
           

NYC Retirees Protest with National Organizations Against Mayor Eric Adams Monday, September 30, 2024



 
September 29, 2024

Contact: Jessica Bassett, Be A Hero,  jessica@beaherofund.com,
Contact: Dr. Betty Kolod, PNHP NY Metro,  bettykolod@gmail.com,
City Hall Site Contact: Marianne Pizzitola, NYC Retirees, marianne.pizzitola@gmail.com
Aetna Site Contact: Sarah Shapiro, CROC, sarahmorah@gmail.com


MONDAY: New Yorkers Tell Mayor Adams, “Stop trying to take Medicare away from NYC retirees!” 

Hundreds of Protestors to Demonstrate at City Hall and Aetna Offices

“Eric Adams may have just been indicted, but he lost our trust years ago when launched a costly legal battle to take away NYC retirees’ access to Medicare.”

What: In the wake of Mayor Eric Adams’s indictment on five counts of bribery, fraud, and campaign finance violations, hundreds of New Yorkers will protest at City Hall on Monday to demand the City immediately drop Adams’s push to take Medicare away from NYC public service retirees. Hundreds of people including NYC retirees, doctors, nurses, and healthcare advocates will deliver a petition with tens of thousands of signatures. 

Demonstrators will then march to Aetna CVS Health’s offices and stage street theater denouncing the insurance corporation’s profiteering at the expense of the health and lives of seniors and people with disabilities. 

When/Where: Monday, September 30.
  • Brief speaking program begins at 11:30am at City Hall Park near the Jacob Wrey Mould fountain. 
  • Protesters will march from City Hall to Spring Street Park where a demonstration and brief street theater stunt will take place at 1:30pm outside Aetna CVS Health’s One Soho Square offices. 

Images: Hundreds of people are expected to participate in the protest, including seniors and healthcare professionals carrying signs with Mayor Adams’s face and messaging about deadly delays and denials of necessary healthcare by insurance corporations like Aetna CVS Health that run Medicare Advantage plans. 

Speakers: NYC retirees personally affected by the Mayor’s push to force Medicare-eligible retirees into Medicare Advantage plans; healthcare workers; and family members of people who have been harmed by insurance company greed that delays and denies life-saving healthcare.   

Context: Since 2021, New York City Mayor Eric Adams and his administration have been fighting a costly legal battle to push public retirees including teachers, police officers, sanitation workers, 9/11 first responders and other public servants onto privatized Medicare Advantage plans and strip away their access to Medicare benefits. The city’s plan has been rejected by the courts multiple times, and yet the Mayor continues to pursue the plan to hand over retiree healthcare benefits to profit-driven insurance corporations. Adams is specifically pursuing a contract with Aetna CVS Health, even though the switch to Medicare Advantage would benefit Adams and for-profit insurance companies but would not save the City a dime. 

Recent investigations have found that the largest insurers in Medicare Advantage have committed widespread fraud and denied patients critical care they were supposed to provide by law; more broadly, they limit provider networks, delay care, and routinely deny claims in order to turn massive profits at the expense of retirees’ health. 

Medicare open enrollment season begins on October 15. Read more about the protesters’ demands to Mayor Adams and to Aetna

###
 


September 30, 2024

Mayor Eric Adams

Office of the Mayor

City Hall

New York, NY 10007


Mayor Adams:


For the last three years, your administration has fought to strip New York City’s public service retirees of their promised Medicare benefits. The teachers, police officers, fire fighters, sanitation workers, engineers, 9/11 first responders, and all public servants who dedicated their careers to making New York City the greatest city on the planet deserve the retirement benefits they were promised over the course of decades. Your relentless campaign to strip retirees of these benefits is not only an insult to their service, but it has continuously been ruled as illegal. Your ongoing efforts to force retirees into a Medicare disAdvantage plan is a drain on City resources and is a shameful dereliction of your duty to serve and protect all New Yorkers. Therefore, we demand that you:


  1. Stop forcing retirees into Aetna’s Medicare Advantage plan by immediately withdrawing your appeal in Bentkowski v. The City of New York.


  1. Commit to honoring the promise made to retirees by ensuring affordable access to a traditional Medicare plan with supplemental (MediGap) coverage.


  1. Commit to not increasing the cost of health benefits to public service retirees by withdrawing your appeal in NYC Org. of Pub. Serv. Retirees, Inc. v Campion.


  1. Immediately rescind the recent decision to charge a $15 copay for each interaction with the healthcare system.


  1. Hold a public town hall meeting with retirees to hear retirees’ concerns and engage in a good faith discussion about the future of their promised benefits.


  1. Publicly state your support for a resolution in the City Council to never strip retirees of their promised benefits, specifically by ensuring access to Traditional Medicare with a supplemental plan.


  1. Publicly state your support for Senate Bill 8388 / Assembly Bill 7866, which would prohibit public employers from diminishing health benefits for retirees by forcing them into the privatized so-called “Medicare Advantage” plans.


  1. Publicly state your support for federal legislation that would expand Traditional Medicare to cover vision, hearing and dental benefits, add a cap on out of pocket expenses to beneficiaries, reduce Part B premiums and recoup overpayments to insurance companies offering Medicare disAdvantage plans.


  1. Publicly state your support for federal legislation that would remove the word “Medicare” from the name of Part C plans.


It is time for your administration to make good on the promises made to the public servants who worked for The City of New York!


Sincerely, 


Be A Hero

New York City Organization of Public Service Retirees

Northwest Bronx Community and Clergy Coalition

Citizen Action of NY
New York Progressive Action Network

Cross-Union Retirees Organizing Committee (CROC NY) 

Physicians for a National Health Program

Physicians for a National Health Program - NY Metro

Center for Health and Democracy

Puget Sound Advocates for Retirement Action

People’s Action 

 

 

 

 

Aetna CVS Health September 30th, 2024

1 Soho Square

New York, NY, 10013


Re: Egregious behavior by your corporation and immediate request for a meeting


Dear Karen Lynch:


We write to you on behalf of Physicians for a National Health Program - NY Metro, New York Progressive Action Network, Cross-union Retirees Organizing Committee, NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees, Citizen Action NY, Be A Hero, Northwest Bronx Community Clergy and Coalition, New York Statewide Senior Action Network, Radical Elders, and ACT UP New York. We are a growing group of organizations and individuals in New York that are incredibly concerned about the increased profiteering of American healthcare by your corporation - especially via the Medicare Advantage (MA) program. Using the MA program, insurance corporations are not only overbilling US taxpayers by up to $140 billion each year, but you are also carrying out severe harms based on your practices - all while you pocket billions of dollars in profits each quarter.


The MA program was sold as a way to cut costs, increase choice, and improve health outcomes: in practice, it has demonstrably achieved the opposite of each of those stated goals. MedPAC consistently highlights the absence of meaningful data supporting claims of improvement; in fact, the Journal of Clinical Oncology released a study in 2022 outlining the adverse outcome for cancer patients on Medicare Advantage. Limited networks do exactly what they are designed to do: reduce the amount of choice available to patients. The large quantity of beneficiaries that choose to sign up for an MA plan (a fact which insurance corporations love to point to as evidence of their quality of care) is in reality rarely a choice at all: lower-income people cannot afford to pay for the Medicare supplement plans that wealthier Medicare beneficiaries overwhelmingly prefer. Moreover, cities and companies are choosing to shift their retirees to privatized MA plans to cut costs - to the dismay of employees who have been promised Traditional Medicare plus Medigap.


Private health insurance corporations denied legitimate claims 18% of the time in MA. For privatized Medicaid, private health insurance corporations denied claims up to 41% of the time. Medical debt is such a problem that the Biden administration announced a proposal to eliminate medical debt from credit reports. The increasing prevalence of prior authorization is seen as a “medical roadblock,” and is being met with growing scrutiny by the general public.


In New York City in particular, public service retirees are dismayed at Aetna CVS Health’s negotiations with Mayor Eric Adams to force retirees onto privatized, for-profit MA plans. For decades, New York City public retirees, including teachers, police officers, sanitation workers, 9/11 first responders and other public servants have been promised healthcare benefits through the trusted Medicare program with a Medigap supplement. This combination is something many have come to rely on, and the unwelcome shift will not only interrupt their current access to care and doctor-patient relationships, but also betrays their decades of service.


Aetna CVS Health’s profiteering of the healthcare of America’s most vulnerable populations is not only shameful, but it is killing people. We demand your corporation take the following steps to remedy the situation:

  • Withdraw from Medicare Advantage contract negotiations with the City of New York

  • Stop the overbilling of Medicare via the Medicare Advantage program 

  • Stop the overbilling of state Medicaid plans by corporate managed care 

  • Stop delaying and denying medical claims. Let doctors make decisions about their patients’ healthcare—not insurance company staffers  

  • Payback fraudulent overpayments to the Medicare Trust Fund

  • Overturn existing denials for treatments supported and recommended by medical professionals and traditional Medicare and state Medicaid plans

  • Do not use Artificial Intelligence to evaluate and deny claims


New Yorkers are beyond aggrieved by the way you use our health as a cash cow. We demand your timely response through an agreement to meet with us in-person within the next three months to respond to these concerns and negotiate an in-writing explanation of changes you will make including reversing the specific care and claim denials in the cases we will bring to you in an in-person meeting.

Sincerely,


ACT UP New York

Be A Hero

Citizen Action NY

Cross-union Retirees Organizing Committee

New York City Organization of Public Service Retirees

New York Progressive Action Network

New York Statewide Senior Action Network

Northwest Bronx Community Clergy and Coalition

Physicians for a National Health Program - NY Metro

Radical Elders



 

           

More Recent Articles

You Might Like