|
The UFT Delegate Assembly should pass the Retiree Chapter’s resolution supporting City Council Resolution 1008 as written--not Unity’s “as amended” alternative.Would you vote for a contract that says “as amended” without knowing what the amendments are? Wouldn’t you be suspicious if you were asked to? 81% of the retirees who attended last week’s Retired Teacher Chapter meeting voted to support a resolution calling on the chapter and the UFT leadership to support the passage of New York City Council resolution 1008. It would guarantee in law that the health insurance coverage of current municipal retirees and their dependents could not be diminished after retirement. But at the last UFT delegate assembly meeting, Sterling Roberson, retired UFT VP and exec. board member, was called upon by Michael Mulgrew to present a different resolution. It appeared to be in support of the proposed City Council legislation 1008. But that resolution includes language about some un-specified “amendments” that are needed. “Resolved, that the UFT supports the passage of Intro. 1008 … in an amended form that protects retiree healthcare, preserves collective bargaining rights, and maintains the UFT’s ability to negotiate future retirement benefits for its members. What is deliberately left out in this sentence is a distinction between members who are in-service and those who are already retired. What Sterling Roberson and Michael Mulgrew won’t say out loud is that they still want to be able to negotiate healthcare coverage reductions for retired UFT members, which is exactly what 1008 is designed to prevent. Here is what Intro 1008 actually says about how current retirees are protected—and about how collective bargaining rights are not affected. “The city shall not diminish the health insurance coverage provided to Medicare-eligible city retirees and Medicare-eligible dependents or the contributions the city makes for such health insurance coverage below the level of such benefits or contributions made on behalf of such Medicare-eligible city retirees and Medicare-eligible dependents by the city as of December 31, 2021. Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to impair the ability of employee organizations to negotiate the terms and conditions of employment, including those concerning future retirement benefits, for their employee members. Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to impair the ability of employee organizations to negotiate the terms and conditions of employment, including those concerning future retirement benefits, for their employee members.”
UFT Retirees can’t grant license to Sterling Roberson, Michael Mulgrew and the current Unity UFT leadership to be able to collectively bargain away healthcare benefits promised us when we retired. Why are UFT retirees suspicious of what Sterling Robeson and Michael Mulgrew have in mind for amendments to Intro 1008 that would weaken it’s protections? Let us count the ways: Mulgrew signed a collectively bargained contract for in-service workers (that barely matched the increase in cost of living) which included secret health care givebacks on the backs of retirees. To achieve those givebacks, they first tried to force us to “pay-up” for a large part of our health insurance. But the New York City Municipal Code requires that the City pay the full cost of heath insurance for municipal retirees and their dependents up to a given rate that is far below what the city pays for retiree healthcare -- so they tried, unsuccessfully, to get the city council to amend the Municipal Code to remove retirees from that protection. Then they tried to force us from traditional Medicare into inferior privatized Medicare Advantage that makes its profits by delaying and denying care – until the retirees voted Unity out of the control of the retiree chapter. They collectively bargained with the city to add onerous health care copays to Senior Care for the first time in 60 years. While the New York City Collective Bargaining law says that neither retirees nor dependents of retirees not currently employed by municipal agencies are actually covered by collective bargaining, Unity’s definition of collective bargaining for retirees is giving away our health benefits and pensions for raises for in-service members.
Retirees have learned the hard way that we need legislative protection to stop any mayor and the UFT union leadership from negotiating away current retirees’ promised healthcare now and in the future. The UFT leadership has shown it’s colors in lobbying against 1008 while pretending to support that legislation. Don’t fall for this wolf in sheep’s clothing resolution! |
Para Alyson Monzon has quickly emerged as an organizer and a strong voice for paras and has been attracting paras to her zooms. Follow her on substack. https://alymonzon19.substack.com/ and Instagram.
This is OUR voice. Let’s keep talking, keep listening and keep speaking up! This is just the beginning. We’ll talk soon. #paraprofessionalsstrong #parapower #uftmember #ourunion #ourvoice instagram.com/alymonz89…
And sign up for her zoom on Wednesday.
- In the South and Midwest the new term that’s the political kiss of Death is not WOKE …. It’s DIESEL.
- Virtue signaling turns off the electorate. Meeting people where they are at and what they can understand and process is what good educators do.
- Notice how corp Dems put down Medicare for all, just as our UFT leaders put down the NY Health Act, which is Medicare for all at the state level. While UFT/AFT leadership say they back Medicare All on a federal level, their true alliances are with politicians who oppose it. Watch what they do, not what they say.
The massive surprise blue wave election has driven thoughts that a similar outcome in the 2028 UFT election could drive Unity from power after 65 years in power. I will be focusing on this issue over the next few months and how that election might compare to the one we just had. Maybe a stretch. But maybe not.
I was in Manhattan Election Day Tuesday and Wednesday and oh the smiles from everyone.Then I went back to Rockaway Wednesday evening to the sight of rotting Bruce Blakeman and Tom Sullivan signs. Sullivan was our local MAGA State Assembly candidate who I expected to win due to the incessant drum of his propaganda, but thankfully lost to Pesach Ossina, an Orthodox Jew - and the Orthodox vote came through for him from Far Rockaway. Osina, a product of the local Dem machine, is far from a Dem Socialist candidate, but some local DSA people backed him as a better alt to MAGA. That's the rational wing of the left. We don't always see rationality in the UFT. (I'm a fringe DSA member on the right of DSA - with a lot of skepticism about socialism but more skepticism about capitalism - which makes me an anarchist.) The recent election and the commentary has sparked many thoughts. Mamdani is given credit by the left for developing a winning strategy that crosses ideological lines. Talarico, coming from a different place politically, still campaigned like Mamdani, who emphasized the billionaires and bread and butter over ideology. Ideologists, including many in the UFT opposition, prize ideology over a winning strategy. They continue to resist trying to win. In last year's election and in this year's RTC election, the ideologists were, and are, active and the politics of building a big tent broad-based winning coalition is not primary. Yet, that's how the Dems won this election. There was one big exception: The 2024 Retiree Teacher Chapter election where the legacy caucus Retiree Advocate switched gears and entered in an alliance with NYC Retirees led by Marianne Pizzitola who had an enormous influence on our campaign (I left RA over a year ago). It is beyond ironic that RA and some of its allies want to abandon the alliance in the upcoming election, which. makes Unity Caucus, which has been attacking Pizzitola because they want to take back the chapter and know she is a major obstacle.
In the 2025 UFT election, there were similar differences between the tri-part coalition known as ARISE (RA, MORE and New Action) and the new guys in town, ABC, which was made up of a coalition of long-time opposition and Unity defectors. Unity knows the ABC modus operendi is the bigger threat and focused their attacks - and continue to do so- on ABC.
Fix Retiree Benefits, the new gang in town (I am one of the founders) and aligned with the ABC type mantra, insists on maintaining the alliance with Pizzitola and therein lies a major difference between FRB and RA. (There are further differences but I don't have time now to get into them.) You have to know your audience. And this applies to UFT internal politics. For active UFTers, the audience often starts with their own colleagues in their schools. When you have a narrow ideology and are in a school with a lot of like-minded colleagues, you can get a distorted idea of where the mainstream really is. Ideologues don't seem to hear voices they don't agree with and want to impose their own ideology even if it only garners 14% of the vote. Thus, a member-first strategy is not compatible because they, like UFT leadership, do not respect member voices because these voices might not line up with their ideology. 97% of the candidates that were part of the 2026 BLUE WAVE were NON-DSA but their campaigns often resembled the DSA method - little money and lots of boots on the ground. And expanding the electorate. DSA had some wins for sure in liberal urban strongholds. But even their message was one of bread and butter and that swept this country along with worsening economic conditions in deep blue, blue, and even some deep red areas. (The big loser was in the Wisconsin govt race where she lost sight of the message at the very end). All winning Dem candidates, no matter where they stood on the political spectrum used a similar message that Mamdani proved could work. When Mamdani had only 1% the first thing he did was talk to Trump voters. In the UFT election ABC was accused of lining up with fascists when they declared they were membership driven. In the UFT, ABC and FRB are the populists who are open to listening to members and expanding the electorate, key issues in the Blue Wave. Extra credit This contentious interchange between the NY Times and @GinaHinojosaTX was truly amazing. Hinojosa offered one of the best explanations of populism I've ever seen. Her comments were a total rejection of Corporate Dems' neoliberal formula. In her interview with this SMUG NYT reporter she calls herself an economic populist… not a progressive. While still going hard on billionaires and elites. Her Texas victory is a game changer.
Tuesday, October 27, 2026 Mobs of people have been anxiously awaiting part 2 after I published The knots keep growing - And untangling this one is a doozy I chronicled some of the issues dividing the non-Unity crew, which was very united when they won the 2024 election with 63%. Since then there have been so many twists and turns that is forcing me to postpone Part 2 which was focused on the one-slate revolt of some members of Retiree Advocate, who run the RTC, over the RA Organizers 10-3 split offer to Fixed Retiree Benefits. The 1008 issue is further dividing the groups as you will see below. The latest controversy relates to the surprise reso at the DA offered by retired UFT officer Sterling Roberson, the most likely Unity candidate to oppose Bennett Fischer this spring in the RTC election, to support the new city council bill 1008 to protect retirees from being charged for healthcare. Educators of NYC commented: Sterling (Roberson) intentionally never read or mentioned the resolves in this proposed resolution … INTENTIONALLY.
Hundreds of delegates on the phone voted on a resolution they never read, had access to or were fully informed about.
This is very much Unity’s modus operandi — to co-opt policies that the rank and file is clamoring for in order to WATER IT DOWN. For sure - a Unity scam aimed at the upcoming RTC election just like the 10k para scam aimed at the 2025 election (which seemed to work - but unless Mulgrew and his pal Julie Menin get them the 10k, it won't work for the 2028 UFT election.) Luckily, UFT retirees are used to the Unity scams so we won't be fooled again. Or will we? I'm trying to follow the bouncing ball with a Bennett Fischer and Arthur Goldstein version of a reso affirming support for 1008 --- and today's discussion at the RTC EB meeting. If I don't fall asleep, I will report on it later. Any RTC member can attend in person or remote.
Zoom link for today's Exec Board meeting. 1-3pm in Room 19H.
RTC Executive Board - Meeting Agenda
Tuesday, September 29, 2026, 1-3pm, Room 19H
-
CL Report
-
October RTC Meeting Agenda
-
Committee Reports
-
Proposal for printed resolutions
-
COMRO delegation
Sterling (Roberson) intentionally never read or mentioned the resolves in this proposed resolution … INTENTIONALLY.
Hundreds of delegates on the phone voted on a resolution they never read, had access to or were fully informed about.
This is very much Unity’s modus operandi — to co-opt policies that the rank and file is clamoring for in order to WATER IT DOWN.
Examples:
1. They were FOR Medicare Advantage before the lawsuits by NYC Retirees made it untenable for their attempts to privatize the traditional Medicare plan.
2. They saw that members wanted to be able to ratify agreements with changes to their healthcare … so they added a healthcare committee to maintain control and only supported the DA making these decisions.
I love using TEMU but not for my healthcare. I wanted to get this fake turn to support 1008 by Mulgrew and the clear signal that Sterling will be running for CL of the RTC on the table before I delve into the RTC maelstrom. *****Fix Retiree Benefits is organizing a delegate slate for the RTC election but is still open to working in a coalition for one slate. Subscribe to my substack and get an email when I post. Also - I have been removed from moderating the RA listserve where criticism of RA will be censored. It is no longer reliable. Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026  | | A candidate for RTC Chapter Leader | Last week I went to three meetings and a faux Funeral for UFT Opposition to 1008, after future Unity candidate for RTC chapter leader Sterling Roberson followed his script in "supporting" 1008 which they had been claiming violated collective bargaining, the Taylor Law, and the pooper scooper law. But then again, UFT leaders rarely pick up the poop they leave. There were actually 5 meetings over two weeks and maybe some progress towards a united slate, but the train leaving the station is picking up steam. There's too much to report in this one post, so there will be a follow-up. (My head is spinning. I wish I could write as fast as Arthur - I used to but aging brain cells, you know.) Since last week over 60 people have registered to run for delegate with Fix Retiree Benefits. CLICK HERE to run for delegate with Fix Retiree Benefits. The goal is 300. Some background on one-slate progressA group of RA dues-paying members were unhappy when RA Organizers presented a proposal for the creation of a 13 member election committee that gave FRB 3 out of 13 slots at a raucous Sept. 22 RA general membership meeting attended by around 40 members. The general feeling was that the 10-3 proposal would seriously damage the prospects for one slate. Also of concern was the manner in which the meeting was conducted, with charges of lack of democracy when demands to put it to a vote were ignored, as one RA dues-paying attendee pointed out: You cannot seriously think that creating a 13 member committee, composed of 10 RA representatives and only 3 from Fix Retiree Benefits, chosen by RA, is a fair and legitimate proposal for creating a joint slate! ... it appears to be a proposal created with the intention of having it rejected by FRB.... Many, perhaps most, of those who attended the RA membership meeting on Sept 22 were opposed to the way this committee was formed and were denied a vote on it. A democratic process on our side might have resulted in a better outcome. The RA 15 member Organizing committee (steering) went ahead anyway and notified three men associated with FRB on Sept. 27 (FRB core members are majority women), inviting them to a meeting on Sept. 28. The next day Bennett Fischer offered to let FRB choose the three. This was the first official contact with the FRB since last May. The official FRB response, while leaving open the one-slate possibility, was:The RA Organizers (their 15-member steering) proposal fundamentally recreated the concept of a an election committee that would run the election and vet candidates and the 3 FRB people would lose every vote when there was no agreement. We learned from our experience with ABC that there is a more dynamic way to run an election than we've seen from the legacy caucuses. A rigid structure would harm the ability to win. If there is an agreement to run one slate, I believe the RA and FRB crowds should be free to run their own versions of the campaign. But that's my personal opinion, not yet that of FRB. The response of key dues-paying members of RA to the proposal led many of them to reach out directly to some of us connected to FRB at the Sept. 29th RTC Exec Bd and the Oct. 1 NY Health Act, which I discussed in Has the Train Left the Station for a United Retired Teacher Chapter Slate to Beat Unity?
The train was pulling out but there was still hope to hop on if the dissident RA members could pressure the leadership of RA into an equitable agreement. The pushback on working with Marianne Pizzitola was still intense and we even heard that one member of the RA Org had said if we dropped her they could agree to a 50-50 split. Protests that she was a key figure in our win two years ago were deflected with: but this is another election and we're incumbents and much better known in the retiree chapter. I don't agree, but that's for another time. A mixed group met up after the Oct. 1 NYHA event. An ad hoc meeting after the Oct. 1 NYHA meeting was open and frank and offered some hope and followed by a larger meeting after the RTC general meeting on Oct. 13, offering even more hope. We aimed at another meeting after the RTC meeting on Oct. 13. The Oct. 13th meeting - Part 2 coming soon. (It is written but if I included it here you would be reading a tome. Actually, this alone is a tome.)
More Recent Articles
|