What an amazing age we live in: app-controlled devices, connected homes. So. why aren't I wildly enthusiastic even though I am not by any means a. Luddite?
This is a slightly updated version of an article I wrote on 20 November 2017.
Smart house appliances going haywire. Image generated in Google Flow.
A few weeks ago we had a person here trying to convince us of the benefits of having an app-controlled heating and water system.
"Instead of fiddling about with the thermostat trying to get the temperature just right, you could do it from your phone before you even get into the house."
"So", I said. "What you're saying is that instead of fiddling about inside, I could fiddle about outside instead?"
That's the thing about the internet of things as far as I can tell. It seems sexy and up-to-the minute and all that, until you question what exactly you stand to gain from it. I've been told that we could get our house up to a nice warm temperature so that when we come in we are comfortable straight away.
At the moment, if it's cold outside, we come in, switch the heating on, and by the time we've put away our shopping and put the kettle on for a cup of tea, the house is warm. So for us, at least, an app-controlled home really is a solution looking for a problem.
Certainly, the potential disadvantages outweigh the benefits as far as we are concerned. What if your house gets hacked, for example?
There was an article doing the rounds today on a similar issue, about driverless cars. A security expert is warning that cars could be hacked into and used as weapons. If you look beyond the hysterical headline, it sounds pretty feasible to me.
I wrote an article a few years ago about the internet of things. I wasn't convinced then, and I'm not convinced now. You may find the article useful, as it contains a list of discussion points for the classroom. Here it is:
I’d rather have a robot assistant. I think. Pic by Terry Freedman
This is an updated version of an article I wrote in 2013. Since then, concerns have indeed been raised about privacy issues, especially in children’s toys.
British Gas and I go back a long way. For years they have provided me with heating and hot water, and until relatively recently with energy for cooking too. I won’t say it’s all been smooth running. For example, there was the time when one of their predecessors threatened to get the bailiffs round to my flat in order to read the meter that they had removed the week before. But on the whole they’ve been alright. I daresay were it not for the customary British reserve we’d be on first name terms by now.
Well, it was because of that “customary British reserve” I was taken by surprise by a talk by Andrew Brem, MD, Commercial & Product Development, Connected Homes, British Gas, at the Apps World conference and exhibition I attended. Most talks I have heard on the subject of the internet of things, by which is meant the connecting up of objects with people and other objects through wireless technology, have been completely daft. They all seem predicated on the idea that we actually want our fridges to order stuff for us when stocks run a bit low, for example, or that we want to have conversations with the stuff we own. They also all seem predicated on the idea that we live in some sort of Shangri La, where nothing ever goes wrong.
Just to set the record straight, I am no Luddite by any means, but I have enough trouble putting my satnav in her place. Will my car journeys in the future, I worry, be punctuated by conversations like the following:
Satnav: Turn left in 100 metres.
Satnav: Turn left in 50 metres.
Satnav: TURN LEFT, YOU IDIOT!!
Satnav: You were supposed to turn left. (Muttering: Why do I bother?). Recalculating.
<brrring brrring>
Satnav: I have your fridge on the line.
Fridge: You need to get more milk.
Me: I’m cutting down on milk. I’m going to buy soya milk.
Fridge: I don’t have a code for that. Just buy normal milk.
Satnav: Recalculating.
Me: Look, will you please….
Satnav: Your shower is on the line.
Shower: when will you be in, and what temperature do you want me to be?
Me: Look, I’m trying to concentrate…
Satnav: Recalculating.
We’re told that you would be able to run your bath remotely so it’s all nice and ready for you when you come in. What if you get diverted and forget to tell your bathroom? So you’ll come home to a flood?
What’s that you say? There’ll be a sensor preventing that from happening? Really? I have a sensor in my car that bleeps when I leave my lights on. Except that it doesn’t. It used to, but I think it got fed up with telling me.
I daresay lots of people much cleverer than I am have thought all this through, but my point really is this: most of the futuristic things we hear about are too much, too fast, for most people to come to terms with. Which leads me back to British Gas. Brem explained that rather than trying to persuade people about everything that could be automated, they had taken the view that it would be better to get people used to controlling just one aspect of their lives, that being heating and hot water. Well, OK, two aspects of their lives.
Hence their offshoot (at ther time I originally wrote this at least) connects up your thermostat, boiler and router, meaning you can control everything via an app or website. It seems OK, although I can’t speak from personal experience. This certainly seems a more sensible way of going about getting people used to the connected home of the future, although I am still not entirely convinced.
On a more serious note, there are some interesting questions that you could ask the kids you teach, such as (change the language as required):
Are people ready for a completely connected home? Why/why not?
What sort of thing could go wrong?
What privacy issues could arise from the use of your data?
What sort of things in your home really ought to be connected, and why?
Same question as above, but for school.
Could you set up a project right now in which a physical object is controlled by an app (yes, I know you could, but read the next part of the question), and be actually useful to someone? Ha!
What else? Do let me know if you come up with any other interesting and useful questions, or if you have embarked on an internet-of-things project of some kind.
And now, if you’ll excuse me, I have a meeting with my satnav about that cul-de-sac I was led into the other day….
Postscript
Since originally writing this, automated systems in general have expanded exponentially, and trying to speak to a human being often involves a major effort just to find a phone number. Even then, it’s no guarantee. A few months ago I was dealing with one of those companies that pays you for books you want to get rid of. The company they use to collect the boxes didn’t ring the bell, just put a note through the letterbox stating that I wasn’t in. It proved impossible to navigate their maze-like system so I was attempting to make a complaint to the book company itself. I did eventually find a phone number, only to be greeted by a robot-like voice stating that you can’t leave a message or speak to anyone. So, what on earth is the purpose of that phone number? It is the telephonic equivalent of a notice stat states “Please do not throw stones at this notice.”
My overall impression is that none of these automated and integrated systems works for the benefit of the customer, only the company. I find it pretty depressing.
I’m not sure if this was a joke or not, but last week I discovered, via Sophie Bessemer, an app that purports to do kids’ homework for them. I wrote some time ago about a situation in which you could have a computer write an essay and then another computer mark it, with no involvement from either pupil or teacher, but this app takes the idea to new heights — or depths.
Forward to the past — created with Google Flow
Imagine: in this brave new world the government could use ChatGPT to write the National Curriculum. Schools could then use ChatGPT to use that as a basis for its scheme of work, which teachers could then use for creating course content and assessments — using ChatGPT of course. And then the kids could use an app like this to actually do the work for them.
Thus we will have come full circle and ended up with the implementation of an age-old definition of teaching:
The process by which the notes of the teacher are transferred to the notebook of the pupil without passing through the head of either party.
Postscript
I put this scenario to my lady wife. She said: Why would you need any teachers or kids at all?
Fair comment. Education could then “progress” to the automation level of my internet service and telephone provider. A few years ago, after they accidently cut us off from all digital means of communication apart from email (which we could still get via data), and even though one of the head honchos was on the case, the automated reminders kept coming, telling us how much we owed them for coming out of the contract early (which we hadn’t done). Nobody in the company could stop the process, and we just kept on ignoring them.
As I commented to the guy helping to resolve the situation, there could be nuclear Armageddon with no human life left on the planet, but the company would still be spewing out these threatening emails, and becoming increasingly frantic and aggressive in the process.
Apparently, a local council in Britain has produced a document that, amongst other things, recommends that you “consider a discreet “break card” system allowing a pupil to request a quiet exit or short break when overwhelmed.”
Horrror, by Terry Freedman
Seriously? The kids in tough schools tend to be very street wise. If they see a system, they know how to work it pretty quickly. Even some of the best-intentioned plans fall down because of this fact. In one school I worked in, the school counsellor always offered distressed kids a cup of tea in her office. The predictable result was that every teacher in every lesson had at least one “distressed” kid who needed to see the counsellor, winking at the rest of the class as they left the room.
And where are the break card kids meant to go? Schools act in loco parentis, so kids cannot be left unattended. Would they have to go to a room staffed by a teacher? What if they get stressed there?
Finally, suppose a third of the class become “distressed” at the same time? How are you supposed to teach? Any self-respecting class would organise a rota system:
“OK, you, you and you can flash your break cards on Wednesday, and then next week it will be the turn of you, you and me.”
An enterprising kid might consider offering his or her break card break to the highest bidder.
The area in which this suggestion has been made apparently has a long history of visitations from UFOs. One cannot help but wonder if the atmosphere there is able to support intelligent life.
Peace makers: Shaping the Modern World: The Men and women in the Foreign Office in WWII
I submitted my review of this book to Teach Secondary magazine, an educational magazine in the UK. The first review below is what the magazine published. The second one is what I actually wrote! In substantive terms there is little difference between the two, but you may find it interesting to see what the editor altered.
Peace makers: Shaping the Modern World: The Men and women in the Foreign Office in WWII
(Peter Ricketts,Aurum, £22)
The published review
Reading most books about WWII,you could be forgiven forthinking that everything achieved in that conflict was down to the actions of people in the top positions of authority, such as Churchill, Stalin, and Roosevelt – but as Ricketts makes clear in Peace Makers, nothing could have been accomplished without the skills, contacts and personal qualities of numerous diplomats and other officials.This is a highly detailed,yet compelling account ofthe minutiae and realpolitik that were keyto the Allies’ success. One potentially catastrophic rift between Churchill and Stalin, for instance, was only averted thanks to Churchill’s assistant sharing with Stalin a similarly bawdy sense of humour.We also learn that while it was Roosevelt and Churchill who wanted to establish a framework for international relations after peace had been achieved, it was a British and American diplomat who actually came up with the wording ofthe UN’s founding charter.An excellent glimpse behind the curtain.
My original review
Peace makers: Shaping the Modern World: The Men and women in the Foreign Office in WWII
(Rickets, Aurum, £22)
Reading most books about WWII, you would be forgiven for thinking that everything was achieved by the people in positions of authority, such as Churchill, Stalin, and Roosevelt. But Rickets makes clear that nothing could have been done without the skills, contacts and personal qualities of diplomats and others. This is a highly detailed, but very readable, account of the minutiae and realpolitik which were key to success. For instance, a potentially catastrophic risk between Churchill and Stalin was averted because the British assistant to Churchill shared with Stalin a bawdy sense of humour. We also learn about the wording of the founding charter of the United Nations. Roosevelt and Churchill wanted to establish a framework for international relations after peace had been achieved - but it was a British and American diplomat who came up with the opening wording. This is an excellent glimpse behind the curtain, so to speak.
If you would like to comment on this article, subscribe to my newsletter Write! via this article: Compare and contrast #13.