Climate change has become an everyday reality. Communities, businesses, and nations are being battered by impacts that would have seemed impossibly apocalyptic a decade ago: unprecedented heat waves, destructive storms, crop failures, floods, and ...
Climate change has become an everyday reality. Communities, businesses, and nations are being battered by impacts that would have seemed impossibly apocalyptic a decade ago: unprecedented heat waves, destructive storms, crop failures, floods, and wildfires. Global action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is too slow, and we are likely to breach 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels as soon as 2050. As the global temperature increases, so does the likelihood of exceeding tipping points, bringing further environmental destabilisation with serious consequences for all forms of life.
The causes and physical consequences of this predicament have been exhaustively established by scientists and modellers. The possibilities for decarbonisation, and its challenges, are also well covered in the academic literature. Far less examined are the implications of plausible climate change trajectories for human societies and cultures.
In Climate Adaptation, forthcoming in Oxford Intersections, we seek to offer a thought-provoking body of work from across disciplines, including from the humanities, social sciences, arts, and from Indigenous scholarship. Our central question is “Who will we become?” In seeking answers, Climate Adaptation highlights opportunities to rethink our relationships with one another, with knowledge, and with the world. We seek to stimulate new ways of thinking and taking action for greater resilience to climate instability. Here are a few of the approaches our contributors are taking.
Learning from the past
In a world in which unprecedented levels of production and consumption have become normalised, it is difficult (but necessary) to consider how current economic and social systems could be destabilised by climate change, and how humans might respond. We can learn much from the past. Our contributors explore topics such as:
How have Indigenous cultures survived and sustained themselves despite massive environmental, political, and social change?
What lessons can be drawn from history and prehistory, of the experiences of societies that faced climatic and environmental shocks, especially those that adjusted and thrived?
Rethinking governance, justice, and responsibility
Many existing institutions, laws, and governance arrangements are unprepared for the rate and scale of climate change and are scrambling to adjust. We explore how adaptation at all scales—from local to global—can be restorative and equitable, especially with regards to future generations and those that are already structurally disadvantaged. What transformations are necessary in dominant institutions, organisations, and systems of governance?
Our contributors necessarily think boldly, as addressing these questions will require not simply modifying existing systems, but, in many cases, transforming them to become fit for a changing world.
The importance of place
While the effects are global, climate change is by its very nature a localised experience. Each place, and the people of that place, are impacted in distinctive ways. In many climate-impacted locations, communities and organisations are already taking action designed for their needs and circumstances, often collaborating across governance scales. Our contributors explore topics such as:
What can be learnt from innovative approaches (often at local and regional scales) for addressing the immediate impacts and long-term challenges?
How can place-based communities work collaboratively with central and local governments to lead or help shape their own climate responses?
Between optimism and catastrophe
Public discussions about climate futures are generally framed between two extremes. In the optimistic view, it is possible to achieve a sufficiently radical transformation of global politics, businesses, infrastructures, technologies, and behaviours to halve global GHG emissions in the handful of years before 2030, and for these to continue to drop rapidly to net zero over the following 20 years. In the pessimistic view, this is unachievable and we are thus facing a dystopian world dominated by conflict, mass migrations, hunger, disease, and despair. The former now appears to be unlikely; the latter, unimaginably terrifying. Neither perspective provides a way to explore the space in between extremes.
Our experiences of climate change are already starting to reveal its social, economic, and cultural implications. Our contributors explore its likely ramifications, along with ways to envision and create positive narratives of alternate futures. Is our ability to transform and adapt hampered by our capacity to imagine different ways of being?
Climate Adaptation, forthcoming in Oxford Intersections, explores the fundamental question of we will become—individually and collectively, locally and globally—when old certainties melt away, and new realities have become the everyday experience.
Leading the commissioning of articles on these questions is our brilliant team of section editors which encompasses scholars from the global south and global north, Indigenous scholars, early-career and seasoned scholars, and multiple disciplines and knowledge systems.
Climate Adaptation will be launched in Fall 2026. If you’re interested in getting involved, let us know.
Everyone knows that many salamanders can regenerate legs and tails while mammals never can (Figs.1, 2). If you tell a layperson that you work on regeneration, they will inevitably ask, “How can they do it when we can’t?” For most of my career, I was obliged to answer, “We don’t know”, and reflect on the fact that the key questions of science really are those simple ones asked by lay people.
The great news of the last few years is that now we do know. At least, now we have some good ideas about how it works, although there are still many gaps to fill. The two key concepts are cell potency and positional information. Cell potency relates to the range of cell types that the cells of a regenerating structure are able to become. Positional information relates to a system of signals that vary with position within the regenerating structure and control what pathway of differentiation those cells adopt.
Fig. 1. The axolotl, a favourite animal for regeneration research. Image credit: Jonathan Slack
Fig. 2. A limb regenerating from an upper arm amputation over 146 days. From Wells, K.M., et al., 2021. eLife 10, e68584.
Let’s start with the cells and consider those cells making up the limb of a vertebrate animal. The skeletal structures and connective tissues of limbs arise in embryonic development from a limb bud—a structure consisting of a loose mass of cells wrapped up in an outer layer. The loose cells are multipotent, meaning that they can become any one of a series of connective tissue cell types: bone, cartilage, tendon, ligament, or dermis (the inner layer of the skin). The other principal structures of a limb: the muscles, nerves and blood vessels, are formed from separate cell populations that grow into the bud during limb development.
When an adult salamander limb is amputated, the connective tissue cells near the cut surface dedifferentiate and become a uniform population of multipotent cells very similar to those of the embryonic limb bud. This fact has only been discovered recently, and it relied on a very powerful modern technology: single-cell RNA sequencing, which enables individual cells to be analysed to find which genes are active and to what extent. This is not the case for the cells of frog tadpole legs, which show very limited regeneration. However, it has been shown that grafting of embryonic limb bud cells into the amputation sites of frogs can improve their regenerative ability. So, to achieve successful regeneration, one requirement is a mechanism to de-differentiate connective tissue cells into multipotent cells similar, or identical to, those of the embryonic limb bud.
But this is only half the story. To regenerate a complex structure like a limb, these cells need to re-differentiate into the various functional cell types arranged in a complex three-dimensional pattern. This is the role of positional information.
Positional information is a concept invented by Lewis Wolpert (1929–2021), a public intellectual well known both in developmental biology and in wider social circles. In the late 1960s, he proposed that developing or regenerating systems must have some kind of embedded information that varies with position, such that multipotent cells can look at the positional information in their locality and use it to decide into what cell type to differentiate. Wolpert postulated the existence of positional signals—for example, gradients of diffusible molecules, which set up the system; and positional values, which were a long-term stable representation of the positional information. This latter concept of positional value is particularly important in regeneration because the information is needed not just for embryonic development, but also to be available to control regeneration after maybe years of the animal’s life.
The identity of many positional signals was discovered between 1980 and 2000 through intensive studies of embryonic development in frogs, mice, fruit flies, and nematode worms. They are composed of small proteins secreted by cells, which are often called “growth factors” or “cytokines” in other contexts. They include molecules discovered by biochemists, like fibroblast growth factors, transforming growth factors, and bone morphogenetic proteins, and others discovered by geneticists with weird names like Wnt and Hedgehog. Most of these factors are active during limb development and again during regeneration. However, they do not persist during adult life. What does persist is the system of positional values, which were only discovered recently.
Fig.3. Visualisation of positional values in a larval limb bud. mRNA for shox is magenta, and for hoxa13 is cyan. Scale bar 100µm. From Fig.5 in T.J.Duerr et al. bioRxiv preprint doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.07.607055.
The key elements of positional value are the genes that define specific body regions during embryonic development. Such genes all encode transcription factors, which are proteins that control the expression of other genes. For example, in the limb, expression of a gene called shox defines the middle part of the limb and of another gene called hox-a13 defines the hand or foot. These genes are not expressed in the mature limb, but they are still “open for business” in the appropriate regions. For example, hox-a13 is permanently repressed in the upper arm by a specific modification of chromosomal proteins, while in the hand it is not repressed and so it can be re-expressed when exposed to the stimuli of regeneration. In other examples, there is very low-level expression of the relevant positional information genes in the adult, which can be upregulated in regeneration. There are also some cell adhesion molecules, regulated by the same genes, that keep the cell populations in appropriate groups as regeneration proceeds.
Although mammals use the same genes to specify positional information in embryonic development, these genes cannot be reactivated in the adult. Mammals have neither the appropriate multipotent cells nor the appropriate positional information to enable successful regeneration. This is why “they can do it and we can’t.” Whether these key elements can be rebuilt using the modern techniques of regenerative medicine remains a question for the future.
Over the last few decades, scholarship in the arts has undergone a significant shift towards questions and topics related to animals and our relationships with them. Referred to as ‘the animal turn’, this movement has involved various disciplines working together to critically analyse the conceptual construction and material treatment of non-human animals (and ‘nature’ more generally) in human cultures, histories, discourses, and practices. These studies focusing on human-animal relations have been interdisciplinary from the outset, since they have required communication amongst theories and methods derived from the humanities, creative arts, and social sciences—and increasingly the biological and environmental sciences as well. Accordingly, the range of approaches that has come to be called human-animal studies (or sometimes just animal studies) has tended, even before the development of explicitly ‘intersectional’ theory, to focus on fundamentally intersectional topics, seeking to analyse, measure, and account for the inter-implicated fates and interests of specific human societies as they relate to particular animal species, populations, and individuals. These dynamics are, in turn, shaped by relevant cultural and political structures and practices.
In the context of the more politicised fields of human-animal studies (HAS), such as feminist animal studies or critical animal studies (CAS), intersectional theory often explicitly underpins interrogations of power and control in human relationships with non-human species. Importantly, in these overtly political strands of HAS, intersectional theory is extended from its original anthropocentric form to now include an examination of marginalisation, discrimination, and oppression affecting all living beings, not only humans. Speciesism refers to the ideology that prioritises humans over other animals (otherwise called human exceptionalism or human supremacy) and also favours certain animal species—such as dogs—over others, such as rats (this latter aspect of speciesism is obviously affected by cultural differences). The deliberately anti-speciesist form of intersectional theory is associated with ecofeminism, which emerged in the 1960s and ’70s, alongside other counter-cultural political movements of this era, including second-wave animal rights, environmentalism, LGBTQIA+, Indigenous, civil, and disability rights.
Specifically, feminist and critical animal studies approaches interrogate the ways in which speciesism manifests in ideological discourses as well as cultural constructions and practices. Anti-speciesist intersectional theory is also concerned with analysing and disrupting the various ways in which forms of human-to-human oppression (such as colonisation) map onto, shape, and are in turn shaped by forms of human-to-animal oppression (e.g., processes of species translocation and ecological transformation). Thus, while more human-centric forms of intersectional research have concentrated on the compounded experiences of marginalisation felt by people affected by racism, heterosexism, transphobia, ableism, and classism, it is only when we embed speciesism in intersectional understandings of oppression that we get a clearer picture of how all oppressions—of humans, animals, and environments—are intricately linked, and how humancentric constructions of ‘animality’ (or animal difference) have been used in the dehumanisation of certain peoples and in the exploitation of and cruelty towards certain animals. Intersectional feminist and critical animal studies approaches are also more likely to pair with activist or advocacy outcomes with the aim of improving the lives of animals—both human and non-human ones.
In the field of CAS, the use of multiple disciplinary perspectives and approaches in combination with anti-speciesist theory has resulted in timely and potentially transformative new knowledge of human-animal relations and human-animal-environment connections. Ongoing areas of research include:
The employment of novel historiographies to account for the role of animal agency in historical change;
Feminist, critical race, disability studies, and CAS theories coming together to examine the constitutive links between discourses of animal agriculture and animal breeding and human experiences of disability, exploitation, and incarceration;
Marxist and other political theories explicating the connections between capitalism, industrialised farming, and slaughter, and the exploitation of human and animal labour;
Indigenous critiques of environmental colonisation and the marginalisation of Indigenous human–animal knowledge systems;
CAS and ecofeminist theories scrutinising the gendered components of dairy, meat, and egg farming and the ways that carnism, meat culture, and advertising of animal products rely on certain constructions of gender, class, sexuality, and ethnicity;
CAS and environmental theories examining the interrelationship between animal agriculture, environmental degradation, climate change, biodiversity loss, and species extinctions;
CAS and queer ecologies subverting mainstream environmental discourse, binary configurations of culture/nature, masculine/feminine and human/animal, and the dominance of evolutionary theory;
Critical race and Indigenous theorists decolonising western food practices and historicising plant-based Indigenous foods;
Various disciplines and scholar-activists are developing intersectional veganism in theory and practice.
Many of the articles in the forthcoming “Animals” section of Oxford Intersections: Environmental Change and Human Experience employ interdisciplinary, anti-speciesist, intersectional theories in their explorations of human-animal-environment entanglements, thereby offering nuanced, in-depth critical analysis of various domains of privilege, power, and control. Contributions range from theoretical, textual, thematic, and visual analyses through to empirical interviews and digital algorithm statistics. Authors utilise diverse approaches influenced by critical race, Indigenous and decolonial, queer, posthumanist, ecofeminist, ethological, social justice, cultural history, animalist, disability rights, Marxist, trans-species intersectional, and environmental justice perspectives. Those writing from Indigenous or decolonial perspectives prioritise deep relational connections with environments and non-human species.
Several exciting emerging trends in interdisciplinary HAS and CAS research are represented in articles appearing in the “Animals” section. One important trend is represented by scholars here who offer cutting-edge contemporary critiques of the animal—industrial complex, drawing on both the vast scientific evidence connecting animal agriculture to environmental degradation, diversity loss, and species extinction, and the ubiquity of cruel practices associated with breeding and farming animals for consumption. A second trend involves the scrutiny of anthropocentric environmental theories and mainstream conservation practices, demonstrating the ways in which they construct disrespect or deliberate disregard for the sentience and suffering of animals constructed as “unwanted”, such as so-called “pests,” as well as introduced and feral animals. For the most part, the authors in “Animals” are critiquing western cultural constructions and practices since these are closely connected to global animal and environmental exploitation, and because of their links to western capitalism, industrialism, and colonialism.
If you’re interested in getting involved in Oxford Intersections: Environmental Change and Human Experience, let us know.
As someone who has spent decades studying the evolution of nuclear energy, I’ve seen its emergence as a promising transformative technology, its stagnation as a consequence of dramatic accidents and its current re-emergence as a potential solution to the challenges of global warming.
While the issues of global warming and sustainable energy strategies are among the most consequential in today’s society, it is difficult to find objective sources that elucidate these topics. Discourse on this subject is often positioned at one or another polemical extreme. Further complicating the flow of objective information is the involvement of advocates of vested interests as seen in the lobbying efforts of the coal, gas and oil industries. My goal has been to present nuclear energy’s potential role in a sustainable energy future—alongside renewables like wind and solar—without ideological baggage.
An additional hurdle that must be overcome in dealing with the pros and cons of nuclear energy is the psychological context in which fear of nuclear weapons and of radiation impedes rational analysis. The deep antipathy to nuclear phenomena is illustrated by what might be called the “Godzilla Complex” that developed after the crew of the Japanese fishing boat, the Lucky Dragon 5, was exposed to heavy radiation from a nuclear weapons test in 1954. Godzilla was conceived as a monster that emerged from the depths of the ocean due to radiation exposure. It has become an enduring concept that has been portrayed in nearly forty films in the United States and Japan and in numerous video games, novels, comic books and television shows.
It is not surprising that fear of nuclear reactor radiation has been widespread. In spite of the fact that there are no documented deaths due to nuclear reactor waste (in contrast to deaths from accidents), it is widely assumed that nuclear reactor waste is quite dangerous. In contrast, the fact that premature deaths attributable to the fossil-fuel component of air pollution worldwide exceeds more than 5 million annually generates little concern. Similarly, the total waste produced from nuclear energy can be stored on one acre in a building 50 feet high, whereas for every tonne of coal that is mined, 880 pounds of waste material remain. Furthermore, this waste contains toxic components. Yet public concern for nuclear waste clearly overshadows that for coal, despite these contrasting impacts.
After an in-depth review of the most significant nuclear accidents and recognition of the deep psychological antipathy to nuclear energy, I’ve become increasingly interested in the emergence of an international effort to develop safe, cost-effective nuclear energy known as the Generation IV Nuclear Initiative. This began in 2000 with nine participating countries and has since grown substantially.
In the early years, the Generation IV Nuclear Initiative took a systematic approach to identify reactor designs that could meet demanding criteria—including the key characteristic of being “fail safe”. Rather than depending upon add-on safety apparatus, “fail safe” designs rely on the laws of nature—such as gravity and fluid flow—to provide cooling in the event that the reactor overheats. Another high priority design feature is modular construction, allowing multiple units to be constructed in a timely and economical fashion.
After reviewing dozens of options, the Generation IV Nuclear Initiative settled on six designs that it found to be the most attainable and desirable. Since its initial efforts, countries that have embraced the goals of the Generation IV Nuclear Initiative have been pursuing additional designs including reactors that range in size from quite small to about one third the size of the typical one megawatt reactor.
In my book, I’ve focused my attention on four promising designs. These four designs eschew the vulnerabilities of using water as a coolant that proved so devastating at Chernobyl and Fukushima. The explosion at Chernobyl was due to steam and the three explosions at Fukushima were due to hydrogen gas that resulted from oxidation of fuel rods by overheated water. These were not nuclear explosions. Instead, the four designs I’ve highlighted use liquid sodium, liquid lead, molten salts and helium gas as coolants. Liquid sodium and liquid lead cooled reactors are operating successfully in Russia, while China incorporated a gas cooled reactor into its grid in 2023. In the United States, Kairos Power is constructing a molten salt cooled reactor, while the TerraPower company (founded by Bill Gates) has broken ground on construction of a sodium cooled reactor in Kemmerer, Wyoming. These are intended to be models for replacing coal fired power plants with Generation IV nuclear plants. Multiple implementations of this approach are planned through the early 2030s.
Given the world-wide interest in Generation IV reactor development and the many initiatives that are being pursued, it is likely that at least some of these projects will come to fruition in the near future. While success is not guaranteed, there is clearly a need for the general public and students to be kept informed of progress leading up to 2030 and beyond.
To help bridge the knowledge gap in this rapidly evolving domain, I’ve launched a newsletter on Substack called “Nuclear Tomorrow.” It’s written for anyone concerned with the intersection of public policy, energy generation, and its impact on global warming. I hope it serves as a resource for those seeking clarity in a complex and consequential field.
Animals caring for their young, such as a lioness carrying her cub by their scruff or a matriarchal elephant herd nursing young calves, are the kinds of behavior that many would pay good money to watch on a safari. However, fish, especially father fish, caring for their young has received limited popular attention, except maybe for the clownfish father-son duo featured in Finding Nemo. Findings published in the recent article “Parental care drives the evolution of male reproductive accessory glands across ray-finned fishes” in the journal Evolution by a group of scientists in Canada shed new light on the evolution of fish paternal care. Lucas Eckert (McGill University), along with his co-advisors Ben Bolker and Sigal Balshine (both at McMaster University) and their co-authors Jessica Miller and John Fitzpatrick, show that, among ray-finned fish, species in which fathers look after young evolved reproductive accessory organs six times faster than those without male care.
Ray-finned fish, bony fish with webbed fins supported by thin, long rays of bone, represent the vast majority of known fish species. Some of these species have reproductive accessory organs, which are parts analogous to prostate glands in humans. These organs are not directly involved in producing gametes, but they optimize reproductive potential through functions such as sperm storage and nourishment. They also produce fluids that increase the ability of sperm to move and fertilize eggs. Research on how these glands evolved has focused mostly on mammals and insects, with little known about their evolution in fish.
“Accessory reproductive glands are a bit of a ‘mystery organ’ when it comes to fish”, says Dr. Sigal Balshine, fish behavioral ecologist and co-principal investigator of this study. “Some fish have them while some don’t have them at all. We know of their existence only in a very few species out of nearly 30,000 fish species in the world. Even when they are present, accessory reproductive glands show bizarre diversity which has always made me think that there must be interesting evolutionary drivers shaping them. There was a lot we didn’t know regarding how or when they evolved, which is why we started collecting data on them”.
In certain groups of animals, sperms of multiple males compete to fertilize the eggs of a single female, a scenario known as sperm competition. Accessory glands produce secretions that enhance sperm performance, and scientists have long believed that they evolved as a weapon to aid in this post-copulatory war in organisms such as rodents and insects. Most fish biologists assumed fish reproductive accessory glands followed the same evolutionary trend. However, in their study, Eckert and colleagues shift the focus away from sperm competition towards parental care. These authors reconstruct the evolutionary history of reproductive accessory organs, testing whether parental care and/or mate competition among males contributed to their evolution.
“There was evidence that these organs were super important in the species that have them, in securing reproductive success and fitness through a variety of functions. In that context, when some species have them and some don’t, the most obvious question was what were the drivers that selected for their evolution in the first place.” says Lucas Eckert, PhD student and lead author of the study, and one of the many students who have been collecting these data since 2017.
The team approaches this question using a quantitative synthesis of phylogenetic, morphological, and behavioral trait data of ray-finned fish collected from published databases. A plethora of published research data is available on reproductive traits of fishes, owing to their remarkable diversity in reproductive organs and behaviors. However, previous studies mostly only describe these traits, without formally testing any hypotheses regarding their evolution. In this study, the authors compile reproductive trait data for over 600 fish species from research conducted over many decades, to quantify the influence that sperm competition and parental care have had in shaping the accessory glands.
In this study, we have been able to put existing data and methods together in ways that they have not been connected before”, says Dr. Ben Bolker, mathematical biologist and co-principal investigator of the study. “This study has been able to find ways to ask the question and find, how much sperm competition and parental care contribute to the evolution of accessory reproductive organs of ray-finned fish, rather than ask what exactly caused accessory glands to evolve, because in biology everything does everything”.
Left: Upside-down round goby (Neogobius melanostomus) male guarding his eggs. Photo by Sina Zarini. Right: Simplified phylogeny highlighting the main ray-finned fish groups in which accessory glands are present (red branches). Illustration by Lucas Eckert.
The special benefits accessory glands provide male fish for improving their reproductive success explains why they evolved faster in species with paternal care. Unlike in many other animal groups where mothers take care of their young, when it comes to fish, that duty was most commonly delegated to fathers by evolution: they had the resources to maximize the survival of fertilized eggs, such as territory, security and nutrition. Accessory glands produce secretions that protect fertilized eggs against microbial infections and increase sperm adhesiveness and the viable period of sperm after release. These secretions allow these stay-at-home fish dads to multi-task in keeping their sperm viable for newly spawning females even while taking care of their young and defending their nests.
Though the evolution of accessory glands is traditionally thought to be driven by sperm competition, this study uncovers a new angle on drivers of fish accessory gland evolution by considering parental care behaviors. The authors hope that these results will encourage researchers to take a closer look at these mysterious glands and consider their potential importance in the species that possess them.
Featured image: Goby eggs by Olivier Dugornay, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0).